Under Investigation for Financial Fraud in Pennsylvania? Here’s What to Do Before Charges Are Filed

Defense lawyer reviewing financial records with a client under investigation for fraud
Jul 24, 2026 - By Daniel McGarrigle - 5 min read

Finding out you’re under investigation for financial fraud is one of those moments that changes everything. Whether it’s a state case or a federal one, prosecutors don’t take white-collar allegations lightly, and a conviction can mean steep fines, restitution payments, and real prison time.

Here’s the part most people don’t realize, though: being investigated isn’t the same as being charged. There’s a window between the two, the “pre-charge” phase – and it’s arguably the most important stretch of the whole process. What you do (or don’t do) during that window can shape everything that follows. That’s exactly why getting a Philadelphia white collar crimes lawyer involved early, before anyone’s been formally accused of anything, matters so much.

How Would You Even Know You’re Under Investigation?

Financial fraud cases rarely start with flashing lights and an arrest on the spot. Agencies like the FBI, the IRS, or local PA detectives tend to work quietly, sometimes for a year or more, building a case piece by piece before they ever move on someone.

A few common ways people find out:

  • A target letter. A formal notice from a prosecutor’s office saying you’re the target of a grand jury investigation.
  • A subpoena. Your bank, employer, or accountant gets asked to turn over records, emails, or tax documents, sometimes you find out only because they mention it.
  • An unannounced visit. Investigators show up at your house or office wanting to “just ask a few questions.”
  • A search warrant. Less common, but it happens, agents show up to seize computers, files, and records.

If any of this happens to you, take it seriously. It means someone is actively building a case, and how you respond from this point forward matters.

Stay Quiet – Even When It Feels Wrong

The instinct to explain yourself is strong. Most people assume that if they just talk to investigators, lay everything out, and clear up the “misunderstanding,” the whole thing goes away. In practice, it almost never works that way, and it’s usually the single costliest mistake people make.

Investigators are good at their jobs. They’re trained to be disarming – friendly, patient, even sympathetic, because people talk more when they feel comfortable. But their purpose in that conversation is to gather evidence, not to help you. Fraud cases usually come down to proving intent: did you mean to deceive someone, or did you make an honest mistake? Casual statements, offhand comments, even attempts to explain yourself can end up reframed as proof of intent.

If an agent or detective wants to talk to you, it’s fine, and smart, to say you won’t answer questions without your attorney present. That’s not an admission of guilt. It’s just common sense.

Two Things You Should Never Do

Once someone realizes they’re under investigation, panic sets in, and panic leads to bad decisions. Two in particular can turn a survivable situation into a much worse one.
Don’t touch the evidence. Deleting emails, shredding statements, wiping a hard drive, none of that makes the original allegations disappear, and if investigators find out (they usually do), you’re now facing an obstruction of justice charge on top of whatever else was in play. Obstruction cases stick even when the underlying fraud allegation falls apart.

Don’t talk about the case with coworkers, business partners, or friends. It’s tempting to vent or ask for advice, but any of those conversations can end up in an investigator’s file. People get pressured into becoming cooperating witnesses more often than you’d think, and a casual remark made in confidence doesn’t always stay confidential. Save the details for your attorney.

Why Getting a Lawyer Early Actually Changes the Outcome

A lot of people wait until they’re arrested to call a lawyer. By then, the government has usually had months, sometimes years – to build its case, and you’re playing catch-up from the start.
Bringing in an experienced Philadelphia white collar crimes lawyer during the pre-charge phase flips that dynamic. Your attorney becomes the buffer between you and investigators, handling communication so you’re not the one navigating a conversation designed to trip you up.

They can also start their own work in parallel, pulling financial records, bringing in forensic accountants, and building a defense before the prosecutor has even decided whether to move forward. In some cases, that groundwork is enough for a lawyer to sit down with prosecutors directly and make the case that charges shouldn’t be filed at all.

Conclusion

Being investigated for financial fraud in Pennsylvania is not a situation to sit with quietly and hope it resolves on its own. Prosecutors have resources, time, and a team dedicated to building cases like this. You don’t have to match that alone.

Stay silent with investigators, leave your records untouched, and get a defense attorney involved as early as possible. Those three things, done right, can be the difference between charges never being filed and a case that follows you for years.

 

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: 1. Does being investigated mean I'll definitely be charged?

A: No. Investigations often end without charges ever being filed. Prosecutors weigh the evidence before deciding whether a case is strong enough to move forward, and early legal intervention can influence that decision.

Q: 2. Can I talk to investigators if I haven't done anything wrong?

A: It's generally not a good idea. Even innocent explanations can be misread or used out of context, especially in fraud cases where intent is the central issue. Let your attorney handle communication with investigators, regardless of guilt or innocence.

Q: 3. What happens if I already talked to investigators before hiring a lawyer?

A: It's not too late to get help. An attorney can review what was said, assess the potential impact, and build a strategy going forward. The sooner you bring them in, the more they can do to limit any damage.

Q: 4. Is deleting old emails or files always considered obstruction?

A: Not necessarily, routine record retention practices are fine if done before you're aware of an investigation. But once you know you're being investigated, deleting or altering anything related to the case can lead to a separate obstruction charge, even if the underlying fraud allegations don't hold up.

Q: 5. How soon should I contact a white collar crimes lawyer?

A: As soon as you suspect you're under investigation, ideally before you're contacted directly by law enforcement. The pre-charge phase is when an attorney has the most room to intervene, gather favorable evidence, and potentially prevent charges from being filed at all.

Get Free Consultation

About Author

Daniel McGarrigle

Daniel (Dan) McGarrigle is a criminal defense lawyer serving Delaware County and the Philadelphia region. As founder of the McGarrigle Law Firm, he has successfully defended clients in cases ranging from DUI and drug charges to serious felonies and appeals. Known for his strategic approach and relentless advocacy, Daniel is dedicated to protecting his clients’ rights and freedom.

Visit Profile

MEDIA, DELCO OFFICE

117-119 North Olive Street
Media, PA 19063
Phone: 610.566.3010
Text: 215.544.2837
Fax: 610.566.4849
Google Directions/Map

PHILADELPHIA OFFICE

1500 Walnut Street, Suite 1060
Philadelphia, PA 19102
Phone: 215.701.4653
Text: 215.544.2837
Fax: 215.220.2611
Google Directions/Map